How can an MCST compare landscape maintenance quotes with different crew sizes?
Give every bidder the same site plan and describe the condition you expect in each area. A larger crew and a longer visit each tell you something about the proposed method. To compare value, you also need to know what the team will deliver and how your managing agent can check it. Singapore's tripartite best-sourcing advisory recommends specifying service outcomes and allowing providers to propose how to meet them.
What to do
- Walk the estate with bidders and mark contrasting areas on one plan. At a pedestrian gate, mark the hedge line that must stay clear of the opening. In a flowering bed, identify plants whose buds should remain through the flowering period. Photograph existing gaps and damaged plants so all bidders price from the same starting condition.
- For each area, record the desired condition, inspection point, frequency of checks and response expected if the condition slips. For the gate hedge, a managing agent can open the gate fully and photograph any branches obstructing its travel. Agree when the contractor will acknowledge the report, who will arrange access and when the agent will recheck the opening.
- Request a separate price for correcting defects that already exist at handover. Have bidders state which replacements, removal of cut material and return visits their recurring fee covers. Where access is time-limited, disclose the permitted work windows before comparing deployment plans.
What to avoid
- Scoring quotes by price per worker alone. A team using different equipment may maintain the same area in fewer hours. Ask each bidder to demonstrate how its proposed work cycle meets the same inspection criteria.
- Applying a uniform clipped appearance to every bed. That can reward a contractor for removing flower buds in an area the estate wants in bloom. Agree on a different inspection point for the flowering bed and identify any edges that still need clearance.
A practical check
Suppose one bidder offers three short visits and another offers one longer visit each week. Give both the same scenario: a gate hedge obstructs the entrance the morning after a scheduled visit. Ask when someone will attend and whether the quoted fee includes the return. The answers reveal a service difference the weekly totals conceal.
MOM best-sourcing guidance for service buyers links to the tripartite advisory. The gate and planting-bed examples are suggested checks for an estate to adapt.
LeaforaGet in touch